| |
Kick-starting the new C-blog section is Carlos, our C-team journalist living in Venezuela. The past week (end May 2007), there has been student protests at his university calling for 'Freedom of Expression'.
BREAKING NEWS BY CARLOS
Caracas, Venezuela May 2007
For a month now, tension has dominated the Venezuelan people scape. Mass media is the target; president
Hugo Chávez gave an ultimatum to RCTV (Radio Caraças Television, a popular TV channel) denouncing its
53 years on air.
The country is divided (it has been like that since 2000) and right now things are getting worse because of
constant struggles between both sides of the officials and opponents.
The government announced it had several reasons for revoking the RCTV license (partiality, violence on TV,
and other anomalies from current law). Public opinion might differ on it. But I am going to try to give a balanced
reportage with my opinion on the events that is unfolding.
Universities (like UCV, USB, UCAB, USM, UNIMET) and its students decide to walk out in protest. They all
carried the same slogan “Libertad de Expresión” (Freedom of Speech).
|
| |
Students writing slogans in support of freedom of speech on motor vehicles that wanted to join the cause.
Photo credit: ‘El papel de la Bolivar’ (USB newspaper). |
| |
|
| |
Friday 25th May
RCTV Station spent its last 2 days to practically “beg” to stay on air. It might have looked a bit
dramatic. Actors and technicians gave their viewpoint, looking for justice. Some people saw this as
manipulation. Students and workers grew in support for RCTV. |
| |
|
| |
Friday 25th: RCTV reporters covering the events.
Photo credit: ÔEl papel de la BolivarÕ (USB newspaper). |
| |
|
| |
Sunday 27th May
At 11.59pm after the national anthem, RCTV’s signal transmission was snuffed out.
On one extreme of reactions, sirens started ringing as way of protest; and on the other fireworks celebrated
and introduced the new television channel TVes (Televisora Venezolana Social) or Venezuelan Social Television.
(I don’t know what I felt, I was just confused)
The new state channel TVes claimed to “support” national productions and talents, and providing true
information, implying that RCTV wasn’t doing it right. Lil Rodriguez (TVes President) said that it is hard for TVes
to adapt a new model and 53 years without a “social television” didn’t make it any easier. |
| |
|
RCTV transmission replaced by the premiere of TVes. |
| |
|
| |
Monday 28th May
I went to USB (Universidad Simón Bolivar) my uni as I do every morning … and what do I see?
Another protest rally surrounded by cops and Globovisión (another independent TV channel) transmitted these
images as well as of another protest in the capital city. Some of them brewed trouble and disturbances; there
were also some reports of aggression and the wounded. |
| |
|
| |
Universidad Simón Bolivar (USB) students protesting on one side,
and the PM (Metropolitan Police) line-up on
the other.
Photo credit: ‘El papel de la Bolivar’ (USB newspaper). |
| |
|
| |
Tuesday 29th May
I stayed at home, and watched Chávez in a live speech, warning Globovisión for its supportive
stance on disturbances. The station was said to be breaking some laws as well. Ministers and politicians
debated about the events on TV. Juan Barreto (Metropolitan Mayor) said there were about 107 students under
18 years old and 60 adults detained (This information was later denied).
Students proceeded to the OEA (Organization of American States) for a public dialogue, thus uniting all
universities around the country. Government ministers said the student protest groups had the intention of
looking for “deaths” rather than “justice” (Blame for deaths would naturally fall on the authorities). It is widely
known that international TV stations tend to broadcast sensationalist and distorted news when reporting
on local events. What I can say, university students really want to be heard and make a difference. |
| |
|
| |
Students from various universities going to OEA (Organizacion de
Estados Americanos)
or Organization of American States.
Photo credit: ‘El papel de la Bolivar’ (USB newspaper). |
| |
|
| |
Thursday 31st May
At the request of university students around the country, a press conference with a panel
of journalists and media representatives was held at USB (Universidad Simon Bolivar). Students wanted to
express why they had a walkout, what they wanted to achieve with the protests and what they wanted the
government to do. |
| |
|
| |
Sunday 3rd June
There will be a national peace march held by students (teachers voiced that they wanted to
join it) at Caraças. It will be to clarify that the main purpose for protesting is justice, not disturbance.
“The march’s main purpose is to show the Venezuelan student union is strong … to clarify slanders about the
movement against current government held around the whole country” said Natasha Ascanio, engineering
student (USB). She adds “the assembly must recognize the pacifist movement … not support the aggression …
we are defending our rights, not trying to make violent protests. ”
Younger students were supporting the protest as well. “It is unfair that students weren’t able to express what we
feel, we are the future of this country” said Michelle Gomez, a high school student (she wants to study
journalism). Students from UNEFA and UBV support the decision made by the president for shutting down RCTV with their
own walkouts. |
| |
|
| |
Tuesday June 5th
Students think that there was excessive use of “force” by the police, and the universities
agree with us. Opinions were expressed on news programmes throughout the night. We soon realise that it was
not simply a dispute about “freedom of speech”, universities see it as linked with the new “admission system”
and its “autonomy”.
In recent years, the idea of a “new university” and “opportunities” grew from the creation of UBV (Universidad
Bolivarina de Venezuela) and the “modification” of UNEFA (Universiadad Nacional Experimetal de la Fuerza
Armada). According to the government both universities herald the beginning of a “new era” in education.
Chavez announced in a live speech that there will be no more admission tests at universities because all
Venezuelans deserve education (cataloguing admission tests as a type of discrimination). Some would argue it is
a means for Chavez to gain popularity.
Now anyone can apply to study and go to university. Young people are glad for the opportunity to be in higher
learning - some feel we should aim for quality not quantity. Expansion of student quotas if unchecked for quality,
could lead to deterioration of learning standards. Universities feel the problem is not with the education but back
in high school and basic education that need improvement. Not enough support systems are in place to
facilitate the bloated student population. A friend of mine is attending only two days of lectures and online
courses are hastily being set up.
One student who lived through the “transition” process gives his opinion about the new UNEFA. “First of all a
public institution that depends on government funding does not mean that we want to be the vehicle of political
propaganda; they’re actually obligating us to attend official marches. So we should ask ourselves how credible
these official marches are?” says Renzo Ortega, an engineering student at UNEFA. He adds that “the
government should start improving the state of university buildings - we still lack a proper library and laboratories
are ill-equipped for the increasing number of students” (there was an incident where too many students
attending led to chaos and the collapse of a building ). A few nights ago I watched a TV programme that posed same question to those who oppose the government -
how credible are the opposition marches? On this official broadcast show they showed an intercepted phone
conversation, where some opposition leaders implied the marches as a previously-prepared event, that the
students were manipulated for a political agenda for the opposition. I can only speak up for what I believe in and what I have witnessed - the assemblies and open meetings held at
my university (USB) to talk about recent events, in my opinion, were not orchestrated by the political parties. I
believe it is a question of basic rights, we as students do think about the future, if we see something that could
affect our freedom (in this case, someone else deciding what you can or cannot see on TV, or telling you that
your attendance is a political event), this naturally raises questions and will be hotly debated.
|
| |
A few girls (students) gave the cops flowers
as a gesture of peace. |
|
| |
|
| |
Wednesday June 6th
Today another peace march took place in Caraçças … this time students walked up to
the TSJ (Tribunal Supremo de Justicia) or Supreme Justice Court. Two representatives from UCV university and
one from USB university voiced their opinions, and expressed protest against the repression during and after the
pacifist manifestations (date). They argued that they are not politicians, but in their role as Venezuelan citizens it
was basically about defending the right to freedom of speech.
In an interview Alberto Federico Ravel, the director of Globovision mentioned that some USB buses were
stopped at the toll gates as it was making its way to the student marches. He also suggested that Chavez’s
advisers were exaggerating the events and concoting absurd ideas that an assassination “magnicidio” plan was
behind the manifestations so they were the real problem. |
| |
|
| |
Thursday June 7th
A student forum for both government supporters and opponents was held at the
legislative federal palace (parliament building). This assembly was broadcast live on national tv, with international
media coverage. The agenda : 10 representatives from each side are given 10 minutes each to discuss, and
debate ideas and propositions about the recent events.
Midday
The president of the national assembly Dip. Cecilia Flores introduces the event by declaring that “Esto
es un momento historico” (“This is a historical event”), referring to the desire and commitment of students to
engage in dialogue with the government.
The first speaker, Douglas Barrios (economics student at UNIMET) read his notes “debe ser afuera, en las
universidades de manera impacial”, said that for the debate to be impartial universities had to be outside the
boundaries of politics. And “no somos socialistas, somos seres sociales” (we are not socialist, we are social
beings). He finished his speech with the symbolic act of taking off his shirt (a red one, the colour of the
government) saying that we haven’t to wear uniforms to be heard. Then Andreina Tarazon (law student from UCV) argued that Latin American is accustomed to a bourgeois
democracy model, where a small minority group has power over the majority. She talked about the opportunities
that will promote TVes as a social channel, and joked that the inclusion of everyone will not satisfy current
beauty criteria for working on TV but the government was trying to promote equality. When the turn came for the second opponent’s representative to speak, Jon Goicoechea (from UCAB) simply
said that students will keep on marching and “nos retiramos … por ahora” (we are leaving … for now). Then all
10 students walked out of the assembly! I could not believe it, I must admit I felt a little disappointed and let
down by their illogical action. Why did they ask for a debate in the first place, and then abandon the forum? The
president of the assembly questioned how can the government take them seriously now?
4.15 pm
A live conference by the representatives at the USB campus explaining reasons why they walked out.
They said they did not receive what they asked for. They did not want a national broadcast neither were they
looking for a disunity – all they wanted was the government to defend the rights of Venezuelans, stating “los
derechos no son disputables” (Our “rights are not disputable”). |
| |
|
| |
| |
| |
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
|
| |
|
| |
BLOGS LIST |
> |
South America
Nye blogs about her travels in the Latin continent |
> |
Tania's Website
We follow Tania's progress as she sets up a young parents website |
> |
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
|
|
| |
| |
ENTRY LIST |
| > |
|
| > |
|
> |
|
> |
|
| > |
|
| > |
|
> |
|
| > |
Sun 27th May
RCTV transmission replaced
|
| > |
|
| > |
|
|
| |
| |
|
|
|